Skip to content

Why EAPs Go Underused at Work (and What Employers Can Do About it)

At a glance:

  • Awareness matters. Employees need to know what their EAP offers and how to access it.

  • Trust needs clarity. Confidentiality, privacy and reporting arrangements should be clearly explained. 

  • Managers have a critical role. They can help employees find professional support without stepping into the role of counsellor.  

An Employee Assistance Program (EAP) can be available to every employee and still be overlooked by the people it is there to support. 

Low EAP uptake rarely has one simple explanation, and it doesn't necessarily mean employees don't need support. 

An employee may know their workplace has an EAP but be unsure what they can use it for, or whether it will actually help. Someone else may expect a long wait time for appointments or wonder whether their employer will find out they have accessed counselling. 

Consider a FIFO workforce where employees spend two weeks on site and one week at home. If workers assume EAP appointments are only available in person during business hours, they may never realise phone or telehealth appointments are available. 

For HR and people leaders, this raises a useful question:  

How easy is the EAP to understand, trust and access when someone actually needs it? 

Comcare, Australia's Commonwealth workplace health and safety and Workers' Compensation regulator, includes continuous awareness-raising, accessible service delivery and clear information about confidentiality and anonymity among its principles for better-practice EAPs. 

Why is employee assistance program uptake sometimes low? 

Many organisations want to know whether their utilisation rate is high or low. While industry benchmarks vary considerably depending on workforce characteristics, referral pathways and program design, utilisation alone does not determine whether an EAP is effective. 

It is tempting to look at an EAP utilisation figure and interpret it as a measure of success. 

While utilisation rates are an important metric, measuring the impact of an EAP is more complicated. 

Employees make decisions about seeking support in the context of their:  

  • mental health literacy

  • trust and readiness

  • understanding of the service

  • workplace culture 

Awareness, privacy concerns, stigma, accessibility, workplace culture and confidence in the program can all influence their decision. 

Program design matters too.  

Comcare recommends that EAPs reflect organisational and workforce needs, including workforce demographics, locations, operational constraints and cultural or language needs. Its guidance also recommends accessible service delivery and ongoing communication. 

That means asking more than "Do we have an EAP?" 

"An employee can know that an EAP exists without really understanding when they might use it, what happens when they make contact or how private that conversation will be. Those practical questions can shape whether support feels approachable in the moment," explains Anthy Wright, Clinical Psychologist and Head of Clinical Services at PeopleSense: Psychology & Wellbeing by Altius. 

Do employees know what their EAP actually offers?

Think about the last time employees heard about the EAP. 

Perhaps it featured during onboarding, appears on the intranet or was mentioned during a wellbeing campaign. 

Would an employee know where to find that information today and is it easy to understand? 

Clear communication should answer questions: 

  • Who can use the EAP?

  • What concerns can be discussed?

  • What access options are available?

  • How do they make an appointment?

  • Who will they be speaking with?

  • Are consultations confidential?

  • What information, if any, is reported to the employer? 

Communication should make reliable information easy to find so employees can make an informed choice. This helps reduce uncertainty and encourages help seeking behaviour. 

PeopleSense: Psychology & Wellbeing by Altius, for example, provides organisations with Employee Assistance Program information covering the service and access options. Its EAP provides eligible employees and family members with employer-funded, confidential counselling delivered by qualified and registered psychologists, with appointments available in person, by phone or via secure telehealth.

How do privacy and confidentiality concerns affect EAP use?  

For someone considering workplace-funded counselling, "Is this really confidential?" is a very reasonable question. Concerns about privacy often inhibit help seeking behaviour. 

Simply labelling a service confidential may not answer what an employee wants to know. 

They may be wondering: 

  • Will my manager know that I made an appointment?

  • What information is reported to my organisation?

  • Are there circumstances where information may need to be disclosed? 

Comcare recommends explaining confidentiality and anonymity protections, circumstances where exceptions apply, and how EAP information will be used, stored and accessed. 

The precise answers depend on the EAP provider and program arrangements, so employers should avoid making unverified privacy claims. 

PeopleSense provides EAP access information explaining its confidentiality arrangements and how information may be handled or reported.

What role do managers play in EAP awareness and uptake? 

Managers may be among the first people an employee speaks to when a difficult workplace or personal issue arises. 

The manager’s role is not to diagnose a mental health condition or provide counselling. They should know what support is available, explain where to find it and give the employee space to decide whether they want to access it. 

Consider the difference between: 

"You should call EAP." 

and: 

"Our EAP is available if you'd like to speak confidentially with a psychologist. I can show you where to find the booking information." 

The second gives the employee information, an assurance of privacy and preserves their autonomy. 

"Managers don't need to have all the answers. Often, their most useful role is knowing how to have a respectful conversation, understanding the boundaries of their role and being able to point an employee towards appropriate support," Anthy notes.

Managers can also model positive help-seeking behaviour to weaken the stigma attached to seeking help for a mental health challenge. 

PeopleSense also offers a Manager Assistance Program, delivered by senior psychologists, for workplace matters including difficult behaviours, workload, organisational change and mental health concerns. 

Is low EAP utilisation always a sign that something is wrong?  

Not necessarily. 

EAP utilisation data can help organisations understand how a service is being accessed, but one percentage cannot explain the experience of an entire workforce. 

A broader review should consider: 

  • Changes in utilisation over time.

  • Employee awareness.

  • Access channels being used.

  • Employee feedback.

  • Accessibility across locations or working arrangements.

  • Presenting concerns at an aggregated level. 

Comcare's Monitoring and Evaluation Framework for EAP counselling services recommends considering whether EAP services are fit for purpose, responsive and adaptive to workforce and organisational needs, rather than relying on a single measure. 

The better question may be:  

What does the information we have tell us about how our people understand and access the program? 

What can HR leaders review to improve EAP awareness and access? 

For HR teams examining barriers to EAP adoption, five questions provide a practical starting point. 

1. Awareness 

Could an employee explain what the EAP is and where to find it? 

2. Clarity  

Can employees easily find information about eligibility, confidentiality, access and what the service covers? 

3. Access  

Do the available options suit your workforce’s locations, working arrangements and needs? 

PeopleSense, for example, offers EAP appointments in person, by phone and through secure video telehealth. 

4. Manager knowledge 

Can managers point employees towards professional support while maintaining appropriate boundaries? 

5. Communication 

Is EAP information visible throughout the employee lifecycle, rather than appearing only at induction, during performance management or when something has gone wrong? 

For instance, PeopleSense support customers with a comprehensive EAP communications package including a step-by-step strategy for the program launch, EAP communications templates to shape intranet pages, periodical service reminders, short explanatory videos and a full suite of tailored EAP promotion assets. 

These questions help organisations look beyond utilisation figures and examine the employee experience surrounding their workplace mental health support.

EAP is one part of workplace mental health support

An EAP gives employees a pathway to professional support. It should not be treated as the organisation's complete response to psychological health and safety. 

Safe Work Australia states that under the model WHS laws, PCBUs must eliminate or minimise psychosocial risks so far as is reasonably practicable. Psychosocial hazards can include high job demands, exposure to traumatic material, low job control, poor support, lack of role clarity, poor organisational change management, bullying, harassment and conflict. 

Its guidance also distinguishes counselling and EAP services from controls that address workplace psychosocial risks. Providing access to support does not, on its own, satisfy the duty to eliminate or minimise those risks. 

For HR and people leaders reviewing employee wellbeing programs, that distinction matters. 

An EAP can provide an accessible route to individual support. Workplace conditions still need to be understood and managed through the organisation's broader approach to psychosocial health and safety. 

Improving employee assistance program uptake starts with understanding the experience around: what employees know, what they can easily find, whether access suits the workforce and whether managers understand their role. 

For more information, visit Employee Assistance Programs from PeopleSense: Psychology & Wellbeing by Altius. 

 


Principal Account Manager and Registered Psychologist with PeopleSense: Psychology & Wellbeing by Altius. Ben has over 15 years of experience in both clinical and corporate EAP settings. He’s spent the last decade engaging with +800 organisations across public and private sectors, extending EAP programs to over 600,000 Australian workers and their families. Ben has worked with organisations to strengthen awareness and engagement with EAP services, interpret utilisation trends and develop practical strategies that support employee wellbeing.

Let's overcome your health challenges